You know, someday, someone's going to have to explain to me just what it is that compels Americans to keep telling everyone how good they think they are.
While we were on holiday, we were moseying around Borders when we came across a documentary taking aim at Michael Moore called, succinctly enough, Michael Moore Hates America.
I share a few viewpoints with Michael Moore. I firmly believe in universal healthcare, I have serious misgivings about the rush to relocate manufacturing plants to countries that pay their workers a few dollars a year, and I ALSO think that George W. Bush is a douchebag of the highest order.
But these days, who the f--k DOESN'T? On behalf of the rest of the world, I would like to take this opportunity to thank our American friends for inflicting this dopey f-ing jizzface not once, but TWICE.
Thanks a f-ing BUNCH.
But the thing is, Michael Moore is just as much of a douchebag as G-Dub. Like G-Dub, Michael Moore ALSO comes up with a conclusion first, and then shamelessly edits and twists the evidence to support that conclusion. So even if his work IS entertaining, he can similarly go f-himself.
Accordingly, when we came across this flick, I thought that it might be interesting. Unfortunately, we didn't actually find time to watch the thing until last night.
Here's my review: It was shite. You could get your handycam, point it at yourself and repeat, "Michael Moore is a tubby, lying cockhuffer who constantly looks like he's pinching a f-ing LOAF" for about an hour and a half, and you'd pretty much have the gist of this film.
In other words, perfectly valid subject matter, but not a very interesting flick.
(Now you know why I don't do f-ing movie reviews, eh?)
In fairness, the film DID have one redeeming feature. The filmmaker (and I can't remember the f-er's name, and I really can't be f-ed looking it up) interviewed the more verbose half of Penn & Teller, Penn Jillette, and showed clips of the interview throughout the film.
Now Penn Jillette is a frigging riot. He's smart, he doesn't abide bullshit, and he isn't afraid to tell someone to f--k right off, and he knows how to express his views. All good things.
Come to think of it, HE'S the guy that should have made a "Michael Moore is a peckerhead" documentary. It would have at least been interesting...
But, as you'd expect from a documentary that was made ostensibly for conservative Americans, the common theme throughout the whole film was that, contrary to Moore's assertions, America is the greatest country in the whole entire universe, and that the stinky, commie, deadshit, pinko foreigners all wish that they could live in such a magical and wondrous place.
And, of course, f--k Michael Moore. But that goes without saying.
Hell, one guy even said that America is so great because Americans and far more self-reliant than everyone else on Earth. Since f-ing WHEN?
Your government pays farmers to NOT grow crops. Your congressmen get into veritable slap-fights when it comes time to decide which state gets the bigger chunks of government militray contracts, because they know just how much of their local economies rely on federal money.
And that's without even mentioning the small matter of the loose change you've just slipped the financial and automotive sectors...
Self-reliant my ARSE. Y'know, I bet the guy who said it hasn't even BEEN overseas.
I SHOULD make it clear that I am well aware of the fact that not ALL Americans go in for this jingoistic pseudo-patriotism crap. There are plenty of seppo folk who cringe when they hear yokels waving their little flags while screaming this "USA is number one" crap. But I'm quite sure that these people know exactly where I'm coming from with this.
For the rest of you, though, I would like to make something completely clear: The US is NOT the best country in the world. Your soldiers aren't the bravest, your people aren't the smartest, and your culture isn't the most advanced. You're no more self-reliant, or innovative, or decent than the people of many OTHER countries.
But you ARE the biggest blowhards. You've got the world LICKED in that respect.
So, if the Yanks aren't the best, then who is?
Easy. Nobody. Every country has its flaws, and every country has its strengths. I'm quite sure that the vast majority of people in the world think that their country is great, but they have the good sense and perspective to be a little realistic (not to mention MODEST) about it.
And THAT'S what patriotism is. If you only see the good in something, then it's easy to love it dearly. It is much more challenging- and FAR more valid- to see the flaws in something and love it anyway.
Waving a little f-ing flag and claiming God's endorsement doesn't make you a patriot- it just makes you a f-ing nutjob.
Besides, when your country has, over the course of a few years, completely f-ed up both the security and the economy of the planet, it really isn't the time to start boasting, y'know?
Later.
Monday, January 5, 2009
Pretend Patriots
Labels:
documentaries,
people,
politics
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
18 comments:
Americans are great at believing thier own ignorant dribble about being the worlds best everything. Time reveals all, however, and I'm sure they're due for a massive reality check.
I agree with LuLi and with you. What's worse is being an alert American who agrees with you and knows that any conversation that steers in this direction HERE ends up verbally or physically violent. Asshats don't like to be corrected, see.
I wish I was an Aussie.
The American Ego is infected with pride and arrogance. A 'massive reality check' is LONG overdue. I've noticed that we lack in business, technology, academics, and ecology. We're greedy, self-centered, and delude ourselves into thinking we are 'poor'. Don't get me started on Christian fallacies that have run rabid or you'll never shut me up.
I love my country the way a mother loves her disadvantaged children. Okay, probably LESS than that, because I have tasted Australian life and wish it to be MINE. haha.
On another note, I LOVE Penn and Teller.
Luli-
I actually think that it'll be an interesting sociological case study when their global power is threatened, as it will within the next few decades. As a people, they seem to define themselves by their global power, so what will happen to their psyche when the Chinese inevitably overtake them?
Sue-
Yeah, I was quite sure that you weren't one of these "rah-rah" seppos, and I know that you are far from being the only one.
No doubt that ego and pride are in excess supply, but these are certainly not uniquely American traits. I still don't exactly understand what part of the American psyche precludes them from seeing anything bad about their country.
I'm sure Australia would accept you. One part of OUR psyche is that we love taking the piss out of people and we REALLY love taking the piss out of Americans. So you'd be welcomed with open arms.
Incidentally, if you are so enamoured with our country, what is it that stops you emigrating? Is your husband not as keen as you are?
Oh I picked up on that when I was there, LOVED IT. I had so much fun!
I felt like I was 'home' too. Even though I never stepped out of Queensland, I felt like I was home. I miss Australia. Sometimes, while I am driving, I realize I doing it all wrong, and it feels awkward to me. It took weeks for me to get used to American roads once I got home. That's bad, eh?
Josh doens't even like to fly, let alone MOVE... to another country.. on the other side of the freakin' planet! le sigh. I'm stuck here. Then, I'd have to fill out, what, a novel? In order to do that anyway.
I need to learn to proofread. haha.
Bummer.
Thank Jah Mary and I pretty much agree on the ideal place to live. It makes things MUCH easier.
Yeah, I bet. This is one of the pre-marital things one should have considered before tying the knot. However, I don't think I can live without him. I was there without him for two weeks and it was hard, but I was home too. Wish I could have BOTH. :-)
Sadly enough there are more of us Americans that believe there should be universal health care and some other things, but unfortunately our politicians and other idiots are good at buying the media and quite a few others to hide what some of us think/feel/ and vote for.
I'm patriotic to the point where I'm proud of some of the ideas our fouding fathers had for this country and I"m very proud of our soldiers and veterans. I work with them everyday and see what a lot of them have sacrificed. And many of them make us aware of the other soldiers from other countries that do just as much if not more than they do.
Andy, I can't wait either! I think it will be so interesting to see the effects of a multi-superpowered globe.. But perhaps Obama will lead them into a more humble direction? Back to their old days of neutrality even? Oh, I'm just wishing on stars.
I am not going to get involved in a great political debate. I think that the media gives us a lot of distorted viewpoints, and short of actually living there, I'll never be able to make up my mind about America. unfortunately because of the media attention (and not just news and documentaries, but movies, sitcoms, music...) gives the world an idea that they know what it's like and what it is to be american.
I just wanted to say: Andy, please review movies! You made me laugh. a lot!
Suvvygirl-
More than the media, I think the real problem is, like Australia, the US government doesn't harbour a healthy fear of the people.
You'd never see a French government trying that sort of shit. They know that it only takes a few dozen pissed off Frenchmen for the guillotines to get wheeled out. Their politicians just wouldn't dare going against the will of the 'republique'.
Luli-
I suppose next to G-Dub, pretty much anyone would constitute 'more humble'. But I'm not getting TOO excited just yet.
Realistically, we're still a couple of generations away from anyone superseding the US in global reach and influence.
And I get the feeling that a dominant China isn't exactly going to be a bundle of laughs- particularly for a certain large, sparsely-populated nearby continent with a surplus of lebensraum...
Helen-
I don't know- I think I've got a pretty good bead on the American psyche. At the very least, I've had more than a few Americans confirm that I'm not a hell of a long way away from the truth.
Glad to hear you enjoyed my (and I use the term loosely) 'review'.
I think the cultural shift of Americans is growing. Many more people there are jumping ship from this viewpoint of 'worlds greatest' to 'ashamed to be American'
We're so laid back and easy going, most countries would look uptight and ego-centric to us eh? LOL
Great post, mate.
x
Whoa. Hold on. While I agree that there is a grand shift of Americans who have jumped off the 'greatest country' wagon, most of us who have wouldn't consider ourselves 'ashamed' to be an American. Maybe not as proud as we were taught to be growing up (and yes, we were taught to think this way in school), but far from ashamed because we learn the truth.
Why would we be? Because other people are ashamed for us?
I am aware that my country is far from perfect, ideal, or 'great', but I don't feel ashamed. I am smart enough to realize it is not MY fault as an individual. I vote, I do what I can, but as an individual I did not cause the problems my country has created.
There is a HUGE difference between knowing the truth and feeling personally responsible for it simply because I was born here. I am saddened by the decisions my country has made (Hiroshima comes to mind as a stark, looming example), but I will not be shamed for it any more than I would shame somebody else for being Iraqi, Chinese, or Korean.
Thus, I have no personal reason to feel ashamed whatsoever. I just wish I was an Aussie.
Smackles-
Yeah, like Sue, I don't know if "ashamed" is necessarily the right word. I think it's more a realisation that they are no longer seen as the sole occupants of the high moral ground, and that they, too, can make mistakes.
Unfortunately, the actions of the last few years has irreparably shifted international relations. Other coutries are going to point to the Bush Doctrine as justification for their OWN pre-emptive actions.
So their epiphany has probably arrived too late.
Sue-
I accept most of that.
I do disagree, to an extent, with one aspect. Personal responsibility obviously rests with those that made the decisions, but I am a firm believer in there being a collective guilt borne by pretty much every member of the society that put them there- particularly in a supposedly functioning society.
For those in the minority, it is obviously unfortunate, but democracy dictates that the view of the majority is inflicted upon the entirety. So while the average citizen bears no personal guilt, they do have a slice of of the collective responsibility.
Just as I, as an Australian, shares responsibility for the actions of John Howard.
I still stand firm. I did not put Bush into office, and the people have no say in who he chooses to serve in his cabinet. My personal actions were in the opposite direction-consistently-so why should I feel guilty or responsible for his mistakes when I didn't want him there in the first place? It is, in this case, completely out of my control. So now, because I'm a resident here, I must bear responsibility for something I've already voted against? No friggin' way dude.
Fair enough. You're not the only person that disagrees with me on this. Hell, you're not the only person who's disagreed with me on the subject this week.
I just think that the result of the ballot is the view of the electorate as a whole, so the electorate as a whole bears responsibility for the actions of their government.
Part and parcel of being part of a democratic society, to my mind.
If that were true, Bush should never have become president. He LOST the popular vote in the 2000 election: proof that the voters don't always choose the president. That damned electoral college is what put Bush into office, NOT the people.
Well, yeah. But such is the drawback of a republic of states.
Our system is even more insane. By the time you've factored in electorate gerrymanders, legislated vote weighting, preference deals and Senate quotas, the idea that the government is actually the definitive reflection of the will of the people is almost beyond comprehension.
And our head of state isn't even elected by the people. We get some handpicked douchebag to represent some inbred old bint in London.
Trust me- I get what you're saying. But I refuse to allow the people to get off THAT lightly. If the government isn't following our will, then it is simply because we've allowed our politicians to get away with not fearing us.
Be it because we have allowed ourselves to be so easily manipulated and duped by our media, or because we have become more concerned with following the seemingly "safer" path and letting our representatives get away with keeping us in the dark, but as citizens, WE are responsible for making our countries reflect our character.
And for a good many years, both of our countries failed miserably.
Post a Comment